Don't I already do that?
Most public super funds offer insurance - with some, it's
compulsory - but many investors still hold their life insurance
outside super. Andrew Lawless, MLC's head of technical services,
says changes during the past couple of years to the super system
have made it more attractive to hold both life and disability
insurance through super.
The abolition of reasonable benefit limits means there is now no
limit on how much insurance you can hold in super; those with
terminal illnesses can now be paid their super (including insurance
benefits) tax-free; and the treatment of total and permanent
disability (TPD) and income protection insurance has become more
tax-effective.
But why would I want to buy my insurance through my
super fund?
Lawless says life and TPD insurance premiums are not normally
tax-deductible but if you buy your life insurance through super,
you can effectively pay with pre-tax dollars. If you are eligible
to salary sacrifice or claim a deduction on your super
contributions, the money contributed to pay for your insurance is
before tax. Your super fund would normally pay 15 per cent tax on
these contributions but because it can claim a tax deduction for
the insurance premium, that offsets the contributions tax.
Lawless uses the example of Sarah, aged 40, who is self-employed
and on the 41.5 per cent marginal tax rate. She needs $1 million of
life cover, which costs $1379 in the first year. If she pays for
the insurance outside super she will pay the full amount with
after-tax dollars. But if Sarah made a concessional contribution of
$1379 to super to cover the insurance cost, Lawless says she would
be eligible for a tax deduction, reducing her tax bill by $572. The
after-tax cost of the insurance would be reduced to $807.
Interestingly, Lawless found that even if Sarah had already used
up the $50,000 she is allowed each year in concessional super
contributions, she'd still be better off contributing the extra
money to super to fund her insurance premiums. She would be hit
with penalty tax of 31.5 per cent on the extra $1379 contributed
but the after-tax cost of the insurance would still be $138 less
than if she had bought it herself.
Don't my beneficiaries get hit with tax if I hold my
insurance inside super?
Death benefits paid to dependants - such as your spouse and
minor children - can be paid out tax-free. If you want to leave the
money to non-dependants, such as adult children, the payout will be
taxed at 16.5 or 31.5 per cent. (Lawless says the "future service
portion" of your benefit - that is, the portion relating to the
period between age 65 and when you die - will be regarded as an
"untaxed component" of the death benefit and attract the higher
31.5 per cent tax rate). But he says it is generally cheaper to
"gross up" or increase your death insurance to cover these taxes
than to buy the insurance outside super from after tax dollars. To
ensure the insurance is paid to the right person, you should lodge
a binding nomination with your super fund and ensure it is updated
as required.
So how does holding disability insurance through super
help?
Like life insurance, TPD insurance is not tax deductible if you
buy it yourself, so it's more tax effective to hold it through your
super fund. No tax is payable on TPD benefits received from age 60
and while some tax will be payable before 60, Lawless says it's
again cheaper to simply gross up the insurance benefit to cover the
tax than to buy the insurance outside super.
The thing to watch with TPD, Lawless warns, is the definition of
disability. Some policies pay out if you are unable to work in your
own profession, while others have a broader definition of
disability and will pay out only if you are unable to work at
all.
If you prefer the own occupation definition, holding TPD through
your super fund may not be advisable. To pay the money directly to
you, the trustee must confirm that you have met a condition of
release - such as reaching your preservation age (55) or becoming
permanently incapacitated. If you are unable to work only in your
own profession, you may not satisfy the permanent incapacity test,
which would mean your payout is locked in super until you reach
retirement age.
Instead, Lawless says, you should buy a "connected" policy,
where the life cover is provided through super and the TPD outside
but you still get a discount for having both.
Income protection is tax deductible both inside and outside
super but holding it within super became more attractive last year,
when the Tax Office announced it would allow a full deduction for
premiums. Previously it only allowed deductions for two years'
worth of income payments.
Lawless says income protection benefits can be paid out of your
super fund as an ongoing income stream and will be taxed as income
in your hands - exactly as if you had bought the policy
yourself.