For a while it looked as if Australia was going to sail through
the credit crunch unscathed, just as it did following the Asian
financial crisis a decade ago. But latest figures show consumer
confidence has slumped to its lowest level since the last recession
of 1992, employment is growing more slowly and the pace of economic
expansion is easing.
The subprime crisis in the US started in the middle of last
year, when mortgage faults began to rise. Now the results have
washed ashore in the lucky country.
"I think that luck has definitely run out. The deterioration in
mood within the past two months is almost palpable," says Dominic
McCormick, the chief investment officer at fund manager Select
Asset Management.
Australian shares - led by the financial services sector - are
down by more than 25 per cent since the beginning of the year. More
than 50 per cent has been wiped off the value of the highly
leveraged and financially engineered Australian listed property
trust sector over the past six months.
Analysts expect the sharemarket to rally at some point but they
are not anticipating a sustained recovery any time soon.
Adding to pressure on household balance sheets are mortgage
interest rates at their highest level for 12 years, steeply rising
petrol prices, more expensive food and higher rents. Banks are
raising mortgage interest rates independently of the Reserve Bank
and they are now almost at double-digit territory.
And the bad news continues. Superannuation returns for the year
to June 30 are their worst for 20 years; the typical balanced fund
has lost between 5 and 6 per cent. Evaporating wealth, higher
mortgage repayments and higher food and petrol prices have
contributed to debt-laden consumers feeling less financially
secure.
Yet many economic fundamentals remain intact and Australia is
likely to keep growing at a faster rate than most developed
countries.
"China and the benefits of the resources boom are still
underpinning the Australian economy but on the financial side and
on the asset price side we have seen some enormous wealth
destruction," McCormick says.
The worst housing downtown in the US in 25 years, falling house
prices in Britain, the continuing credit crisis and soaring energy
costs have rocked investor confidence around the globe.
Economists at Commonwealth Securities now put the chances of a
global recession at 40 per cent. "The US economy is at risk of
taking another [turn] downwards and we are seeing the second phase
of the credit crunch coming through now," says Savanth Sebastian,
an equities economist at CommSec.
"We are starting to see borrowing costs rising again and that is
a big concern when you have got inflation hounding on your doorstep
as well."
Of course, no one knows for sure how long the downturn will last
and markets could make a sustained recovery. But by the same token,
any sustained recovery could be a long time off.
History shows that sharemarkets can spend very long times in the
doldrums.
The Australian All Ordinaries Index, for example, did not regain
its 1987 peak until 1996. Japanese shares are still worth just a
little more than 30 per cent of what they were trading for at the
time of their peak in 1989. And US shares did not surpass the 1929
peak for 25 years. US shares are now worth about as much as they
were 10 years ago.
But it would be wrong for Australian investors to be overly
pessimistic. McCormick says that after some panic selling,
particularly by those who have borrowed heavily to invest in the
sharemarket, value is reappearing in some sectors of the
market.
He thinks the selling of listed property trusts has gone too
far. "We think that the LPT sector is getting close to pricing in
an Armageddon-type scenario," McCormick says. "Even assuming asset
devaluations, you are still talking quite massive discounts to net
asset valuations." (See also story on p10.)
Australian shares have been driven down so far it is probable
there will be a rally. However, McCormick doubts whether that will
signal the end of the bear market.
Shane Oliver, the chief economist at AMP Global Investors, says
Australian shares are now trading on a forward price-to-earnings
ratio of 11 times, which is well below the average of the past
decade of 15.2 times. "While industrial companies are likely to see
further profit downgrades, current share prices are implying a
nearly 30 per cent fall in overall profits. This seems very
unlikely with resources likely to deliver very strong profit
growth," he says.
Fund managers like to point out that the big emerging economies,
such as China and Brazil, are decoupling economically from the US.
That is partially true but the world's biggest economy is either in
recession or skirting close to it. When the US economy slows
sharply, the rest of the world also slows.
China's economy is slowing, even though it is still expanding
strongly. Its sharemarket is down 50 per cent from its peak in
October last year.
No one can time their entry and exit into the market perfectly
but investors should be able gauge whether a market is too
overheated or has been sold off too heavily on the pessimism.
The turmoil on financial markets is again testing the veracity
of the old truisms of the investing, such as it is "time in the
market, not timing" that makes the most money.
But those cliches tend to ignore the realities - investors need
to remain alert to risks and act on them.
So what should investors do? McCormick says people should not
blindly put more money in the sharemarket. He thinks it is likely
that Australia will avoid a recession as the benefits of the
resources boom continue to flow through the economy and offset
negative influences.
CommSec's Sebastian says about $45 billion worth of excess cash
will flow through the Australian economy over the next year because
of the big increases in the contract prices for iron ore and
coal.
"That should see national income increase by about 4 per cent
and we have not seen that size increase for a very long time, if
ever," Sebastian says.
He says although Australian shares are cheap on a
price-to-earnings basis, investor sentiment is being driven by fear
and there is no obvious catalyst for a sustained turnaround.
"It is a global sentiment rather than fundamentals locally and
that is what is driving the market mostly at the moment - the
fear-driven factor," he says.
"But domestic demand is slowing significantly. We have a
two-themed economy where we have the resources sector driving
economic growth and the rest of the economy falling by the wayside
at the moment."
McCormick is clear on one thing - he says investors should
reduce their gearing into markets to manageable levels and that
cash should be kept on hand for opportunities as they arise.